Is Overreliance on AI Causing Agency Decay?
ManagementPsychologyPhilosophy
THE AI ANGLE
Eroding independent human judgment through routine cognitive offloadingWharton scholar Cornelia Walther warns that increasing overreliance on generative AI is causing 'agency decay,' the progressive erosion of an individual's independent thinking, deliberate choice, and personal accountability. As users transition through stages from experimentation to dependence, cognitive and belief offloading diminish critical evaluation and create organizational costs like 'workslop.' To counter these risks, Walther outlines an 'A-Frame' model (Awareness, Appreciation, Acceptance, Accountability) to reclaim deliberate co-agency and protect foundational human judgment.
THE TEACHING ANGLE
Instructors can explore the tension between short-term cognitive efficiency and long-term skill degradation, debating whether delegating initial drafts and decisions to AI fundamentally compromises critical thinking and intellectual ownership.Read the original at knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu Generate teaching or study materials
More in Management
- How Roche drives AI outcomes in a changing worldCIO.com · September 16, 2026
- AI can be more comforting than a person – our research shows whyThe Conversation — AI · September 16, 2026
- When AI agents cheat on math problems, others blow the whistlePhys.org — Technology · September 16, 2026
- ‘I’ve just done about 2 weeks' work in an hour. Do I tell my boss or keep it secret?’ — Nearly a third of AI users are hiding it from their employersTechRadar · September 16, 2026
- Trapped in Someone Else’s Imagination: Students on AI, Choice, and the Futures We DeserveFaculty Focus · September 16, 2026